Author:
Jaime Wolf
<
q2b6
>
187.158.17.57
Use
this link
if you want to link to this message and its entire thread of discussion.
Date:
3/17/2011 4:29:49 PM
Subject:
RE: Top 100 PC games
Now for some real comments:
Red Faction: Guerrilla shouldn't be there, it's a fun game but poorly represented with a crap PC port.
Dungeon Siege should GTFO of there.
Dark Corners of the Earth is a crap port of an okay Xbox game.
Sins of a Solar Empire should be higher.
Mechcommander should GTFO.
Grim Fandango should be waaay higher.
As deep as it is, Dwarf Fortress shouldn't be there, it's an impressive achievement but not much of a game. When it gets an actual budget and a development team that doesn't consist of a gut that spend 10% of his time working on the game and the other 90% eating Cheetos, *then* you can put it back in.
Day of the Tentacle should be higher.
Dungeon Keeper should be higher.
Neptune's Pride should GTFO.
Battlefield 2 should be higher.
TIE Fighter should be in the top ten.
Doom should be in the top ten.
Dragon Age should GTFO.
The Longest Journey should switch spots with any of the lower ranked Lucas games.
Fallout should be in the top ten.
Braid should be lower.
KOTOR should GTFO.
Supreme Commander 2 should GTFO, and whoever put it there whipped.
Freespace 2 should be in the top ten.
Mass Effect should be put where Mass Effect 2 is, Mass Effect 2 should GTFO.
Hitman: Blood Money should be lower, or arguably shouldn't be there, the original should.
Counterstrike, if counting mods, should be replaced with Action Quake 2.
I'm extremely conflicted with Minecraft.
Left 4 Dead should be lower.
Arma 2 should be lower, sure ambition counts, but only if you can actually pull off what you were striving for, Arma 2 is too fucking buggy and unpolished to be that high.
XCOM should be top ten.
Company of Heroes Online doesn't belong there, the original game does, but not that high.
Ultima 7, Rome: Total War , Team Fortress 2, Oblivion and Portal do not belong in the top ten.
